Alphabet's Anthropic Stake Won't Save a Bad Quarter

Alphabet's Anthropic and SpaceX stakes added $77 billion to its profit in Q2, yet the stock still fell. In Q3, an $8.7 billion investment loss helped cause an earnings miss and a 10% drop. Here's why paper gains can't cover for Google's core business.

Share
Alphabet's Anthropic Stake Won't Save a Bad Quarter

There's a popular idea going around right now.

Even if Google misses its next earnings, it won't matter, because its stake in Anthropic is worth so much more after the IPO.

I understand why people think that.

Alphabet owns about 13.7% of Anthropic, and Anthropic just completed the largest IPO in history.

But Alphabet's own results from this year show why I don't think paper gains can rescue a bad quarter.

What Happened Last Quarter

Alphabet reported its Q3 results on October 28.

Revenue grew 25% to $127.6 billion, just below the $128 billion analysts expected.

Earnings per share came in at $2.12, far below the roughly $3.01 expected.

An $8.7 billion loss on equity investments cut about 55 cents from that figure.

The core business also fell short.

Operating income was $40.58 billion, against a $43.2 billion forecast, and free cash flow was negative $9.07 billion.

Search ads grew 12%, below some forecasts, while Google Cloud doubled to $30.7 billion.

The stock fell about 10% after hours.

That's the key point.

Alphabet's investment portfolio made the miss worse.

The Quarter Before Was The Opposite

In Q2, Alphabet reported net income of $112.1 billion, the first 12-figure quarterly profit in its history.

About $99 billion of "other income" came from gains on equity securities, mainly from its stakes in Anthropic and SpaceX.

After tax, those gains added $77.1 billion to net income, or $6.26 of its $9.11 earnings per share.

And yet the stock fell about 3% after hours.

Investors were more focused on Alphabet raising its 2026 capital spending plan to $195 billion to $205 billion and on competition for Gemini.

A record profit, driven by investment gains, didn't move the stock up.

Why Investors Look Through Paper Gains

These two quarters show how the market treats investment gains.

They're real under accounting rules, but they don't come from selling ads, cloud services or devices.

They swing with the value of other companies, and they can reverse the next quarter.

So investors value Alphabet on what it controls: Search, YouTube, Cloud and how much it spends to grow them.

There's also a credibility issue.

Anthropic has committed to buy at least five gigawatts of computing capacity from Google Cloud.

Analysts have pointed out that Google's investments can lift Anthropic's valuation, which Google then books as profit.

As one accounting expert told Fortune, "It's interesting that they're able to control or influence the value of one of their own assets."

What Q4 Could Look Like

The Anthropic IPO does set up a potentially huge gain.

Anthropic priced its IPO at $83 per share on November 18.

At that price, 24/7 Wall St. estimated Alphabet's stake at about $147 billion.

Now that Anthropic trades publicly, Alphabet will mark that stake to the market price at the end of each quarter.

So Q4's gain or loss depends on where Anthropic's shares close on December 31.

If they stay above the value Alphabet last recorded, the gain could be enormous.

But Anthropic's shares fell about 9% on their second day of trading as the broader market slid into a correction.

A falling share price would shrink the gain, or even turn it into a loss.

What Actually Matters For Google

I've written about the pricing power of Google Ads and why Waymo could become Google's next advertising business.

Those are the kinds of businesses investors will judge Alphabet on.

In Q4, I'd watch four things.

  • Search growth, to see whether AI answers are hurting or helping ad revenue.
  • Google Cloud, which is now Alphabet's fastest-growing business.
  • Capital spending, since the CFO said it will rise significantly in 2027.
  • Free cash flow, which turned negative in Q3.

If those disappoint, a large Anthropic gain will make the headline profit look great, and I'd still expect the stock to struggle.

Conclusion: Paper Gains Don't Pay The Bills

Alphabet's Anthropic stake is an extraordinary investment.

But this year has shown that the market doesn't reward Alphabet for investment gains, and it punishes the company when those gains turn into losses.

Now that Anthropic is public, those swings will show up every quarter.

My Take: A big Anthropic gain might make Alphabet's next headline profit look spectacular, but investors will still judge Google on Search, Cloud and spending, so an earnings miss in the core business will matter no matter how much the stake is worth.

Disclosure: I use Claude, made by Anthropic, as a research and writing assistant. This post is my opinion and isn't investment advice.

Sources

Pages I opened for the facts in this post: